Mindful Wellness

HTML Form Maker

For individual articles and topics click on the Subject section in purple to the right image

Why Mammography Screening is being Abolished in Switzerland

December 11, 2014

Why Mammography Screening is being Abolished in Switzerland  PDF Attachment

Whether breast cancer screening does more harm than good has been debated extensively. Earlier this year the Swiss Medical Board published a report recommending that no new systematic mammography screening programs be introduced. Here is how and why they came to this conclusion.

The Swiss Medical Board is part of an independent health technology assessment initiative in Switzerland. In 2013 they were asked to review the current mammography screening program. The team of experts on the board included amongst others a medical ethicist, a clinical epidemiologist, a pharmacologist, an oncologic surgeon, a nurse scientist, a lawyer, and a health economist.

“Systematic mammography screening” is the term generally used to describe the serial radiological examination of women within the framework of a screening program whereby all women in a specific age group are invited to an X-ray examination of their breasts which is not conducted by a doctor. At the time the country had in place a comprehensive screening program which was offered to all women aged from 50 to 69.

The board spend twelve months reviewing all available evidence and its implications. They reported becoming “increasingly concerned” about the widely believed notion that mammograms were safe and capable of saving lives. They said “As we embarked on the project, we were aware of the controversies that have surrounded mammography screening for the past 10 to 15 years. When we reviewed the available evidence and contemplated its implications in detail, however, we became increasingly concerned.”
In fact they concluded that statistics clearly indicated that mammograms appeared to be preventing only 1 death per 1,000 women screened, and actually caused harm to many more. Their thorough review left them no choice but to recommend that “no new systematic mammography screening programs be introduced, and that a time limit should be placed on existing programs.”

The report was made public at the start of 2014 wherein they advised that the quality of mammography screening should be evaluated and every woman should be informed, in a “clear and balanced” way, about the benefits in addition to the potential harms of screening.(i)

The subject of whether breast cancer screening in women with no symptoms has been questioned by many industry experts over the years and this revelation from the Swiss seems to prove that it no longer makes sense.

Two members of the Swiss Medical Board’s expert panel went on to expand on their research and the reasons which led to their conclusion in an article in New England Journal of Medicine (ii) discussing three major factors:

1. OUTDATED CLINICAL TRIALS
“We noticed that the ongoing debate was based on a series of reanalyses of the same, predominantly outdated trials. The first trial started more than 50 years ago in New York City and the last trial in

Click to continue reading...


Share

Comments

There are currently no comments

Submit a Comment

Please be sure to fill in all information. Comments are moderated. Please no link dropping, domains as names; do not spam and do not advertise.

*